A few weeks after our ski trip (see post My First Time with a Girl), I met up with Suzy at a busy bar downtown after she got off work. She told me my hair looked nice. I had straightened it, but also burned part of it on a candle, which I told her and we had a good laugh about the dangers of scented candles.
We had a great time chatting about work, life, the boys we were seeing, while sharing a half litre of red wine. The service was good, and the bartenders were cute and flirty. I felt surrounded by an exciting energy that night.
Nate and I had talked the night before and planned for him to meet Rob and have a few drinks while I did the same with Suzy and then they would come join us at the bar. We would all have drinks together and see where the night led. I’d never strategized how to pick up a couple before and found the planning kind of fun and a bit stressful.
Things seemed to be going according to plan until Nate arrived at the bar by himself. Rob had dropped him off but said he didn’t feel like joining us because he had to work the next day. Nate told me later that he had hinted to Rob heavily about what we wanted to do that night, and tried to convince him to come in. Rob was not interested and also said Suzy wouldn’t do anything without him. It turned out they were not on the same page.
The three of us did some shots and had another round of drinks. We chatted some more and laughed a lot. Suzy said she couldn’t drive home because we were drinking so Nate offered her his couch.
We all cabbed to Nate’s apartment. He disappeared for a few minutes while Suzy made herself comfortable on the couch and I sat down close to her. I felt kind of nervous. I grabbed the remote and started flipping through channels and making comments about the different shows. She giggled.
Nate walked out of his bedroom and came over to where I was sitting. He kissed me hard then took off my shirt. He then did the same with Suzy, who giggled and said “oh this is happening!” He then unbuttoned his jeans, dropped them and stood in front of us, naked from the waist down. We giggled some more, and then I grabbed his dick and started sucking it. Suzy looked at me and said “let me try too” and proceeded to give him a loud, sloppy blowjob. We took turns giving him head and also licked him together. It was very sexy watching her go down on him. We took a break and kissed each other, which deeply aroused me. I felt like I was in a sex trance.
He had bought a double sided dildo and asked us to fuck ourselves with it. Naturally we obliged and got on our hands and knees, inserted each end into our pussies, and began gyrating and humping against each other. I heard him growl “holy shit” and looked over and made eye contact with him. I found it very hot to be fucking another girl and if her moans were any indication, Suzy thoroughly enjoyed it too.
Nate took turns fucking each of us, while the other girl touched the first one or made out with him. While he was busy setting up the sex swing, Suzy and I made out, fingered her and licked each other’s pussy. “You’re so wet” I commented and she replied “mmm, you too” I did not feel jealous at all when Nate was fucking Suzy. In fact, I found it very hot watching them. Suzy watched us as well.
I was too drunk to orgasm despite how aroused I was. Nate didn’t seem to have that problem. After he finished, we realized we were all pretty tired and it was time for bed. Suzy went to sleep on the couch but Nate and I insisted she sleep with us. He picked her up and carried her to his bed, then lay down between us.
In the morning, I drove Suzy to her car downtown and we had a chat. She asked if I was ok with everything that happened last night, and that she hoped it wouldn’t cause any issues between me and Nate. I replied absolutely not, and I said I hoped she and Rob were ok too. I awkwardly added “last night was very fun” with a smile while staring straight ahead at the road. “I had a good time as well”, she replied with a giggle. She then promptly asked me not to tell anyone on our soccer team or otherwise. I promised I wouldn’t. When I got back to Nate’s place, we started talking about last night, which turned us on and we sex again, just the two of us, which felt amazing. I finally had an intense orgasm.